👻 Pizza, Spirits & Supernatural Stories: Discover the Haunted Heart of Spirit Lake, IdahoNestled in the heart of Spirit Lake, Idaho, lies a true hidden gem — a place that fuses delicious food, rich
- Kathy Simpson
- Feb 17
- 2 min read
Updated: Mar 30
Nestled in the heart of Spirit Lake, Idaho, is a hidden gem that combines delicious food, rich history, and a touch of the supernatural. This longstanding establishment, operating for over a century, offers a unique dining experience that is sure to leave you intrigued.

🍕 Handcrafted Pizza & Wings in a Legendary Location
At this historic Spirit Lake restaurant, you’ll find:
Hand-tossed, wood-fired pizzas made fresh daily
Crispy chicken wings tossed in house-made sauces
Ice-cold beer, wine, and cocktails from the full-service bar
Whether you're a local looking for the best pizza in Spirit Lake, or a traveler seeking great food with a side of history, this spot delivers.
🔥 Menu Highlights:
Top Pizza Picks
🍕 Pizza of the Month – Seasonal and always unique
🍕 Build-Your-Own Pizza – Custom-crafted with fresh toppings
🍕 Classic 10", 12", or 15" Pies – Great for solo diners or sharing
Signature Wings
🔥 Buffalo Hot
🍯 Sweet Korean BBQ
🌶️ Chipotle Dry Rub
🥗 Classic BBQ
Appetizers & Deli Sandwiches
🧄 Garlic Parmesan Knots
🧀 Mozzarella Sticks
🥪 The Dark Horse Signature Sandwich
🥪 NYC Deli & The Luigi
👻 Haunted Since 1907: Dine with a Side of Supernatural
What makes this place truly stand out? Its haunted past.
Built in 1907, this historic Idaho restaurant has more than just brick walls — it has stories. From flickering lights to eerie footsteps and ghostly whispers, guests and staff alike have experienced things they can’t quite explain.
It’s not just food... it’s an experience.
🏨 Located Beside Idaho’s Oldest Bar
Right next door is the White Horse Saloon — Idaho’s oldest and most haunted bar. Together, they form a one-of-a-kind destination for:
Paranormal enthusiasts 👻
Historic travel buffs 🏛️
Pizza and beer lovers 🍕🍺
Step into the past, one slice at a time.
🎉 Hosting Events or Group Dinners?
Whether you're planning a private party, a ghost tour stop, or just dinner with friends, this spot offers:
Group reservations
Flexible event hosting
Optional storytelling experiences (ask our staff!)
📍 Plan Your Visit
📌 Location: 6242 W Maine Street, Spirit Lake, ID🕒 Kitchen Hours: 11 AM – 8 PM, 7 Days a Week🍻 Bar Open Until: 2 AM (Perfect for night owls & ghost hunters)
🧭 Why Locals & Tourists Love This Haunted Pizza Spot:
✅ Best wood-fired pizza in Spirit Lake✅ Juicy wings & craft cocktails✅ Rich haunted history dating back to 1907✅ Located next to Idaho’s oldest bar✅ A cozy, friendly local bar vibe✅ Available for dine-in, takeout, and events
✨ Visit Today — And Taste the Past
So if you're searching for “haunted restaurants in Idaho”, “pizza in Spirit Lake”, or just a place with great food and a great story — you’ve found it.
Bring your appetite. And maybe... your ghost-hunting gear. 👻
Comments